1. Home
  2. Extended Auto Warranty

Find the Best Extended Auto Warranty Companies in Milwaukee, WI

With Milwaukee’s rough roads and tough winters, it’s a good idea to buy an extended auto warranty to offset costs of repairs. The many different features of these service plans can be confusing. We researched the best extended auto warranty in Milwaukee to help you make sense of the options.

Take a Quiz

Get matched with an Accredited Partner

    Compare Top Extended Auto Warranties

    Overall satisfaction rating
    • Available in Milwaukee
    • Accepted by ASE mechanics
    • A+ rating with the BBB
    • 4 coverage options

    Total protection guaranteed!

    Visit Website (855) 329-7711 Read More
    Overall satisfaction rating
    • No-haggle guarantee
    • Roadside plans for $59.95
    • Available in Milwaukee
    • Mobile app

    Select 3 plan options with deductibles as low as $100. Covers vehicles for up to 5 years or 125,000 miles.

    Visit Website (866) 254-0172 Read More
    Infinite Auto
    Overall satisfaction rating
    • A+ BBB Rating
    • 24/7 roadside assistance
    • Guarantees 100% payment in event of any breakdown
    • Available in Milwaukee

    A+ Rated with the BBB. Infinite Auto Protection provides coverage for your vehicle in the event of any breakdown and guarantees 100% payment, less any deductibles, of all covered repairs.

    Visit Website (734) 366-4354 Read More
    Protect My Car
    Overall satisfaction rating
    • 3 plans available
    • 30-day money-back guarantee
    • Available in Milwaukee
    • Rental car benefits

    Protect My Car allows a long 60-month repayment plan. Although their Ambassador plan only offers partial coverage, Protect My Car’s other plans satisfy a wide array of needs.

    Visit Website (609) 401-2762
    AA Auto Protection
    • Wear & tear coverage options
    • Resolves claims quickly
    • 30-day money-back guarantee
    • Available in Milwaukee
    Serves residents in
    Milwaukee, WI
    (888) 222-4445
    Delta Auto Protect
    Overall satisfaction rating
    • ASE-licensed technicians on staff
    • Available in Milwaukee
    • Customizable plans
    • Price match promise
    Serves residents in
    Milwaukee, WI
    (866) 598-5429

    How to choose an extended auto warranty in Milwaukee

    Milwaukee Skyline

    An extended auto warranty is a service protection plan. It can be purchased when you buy your vehicle or after the sale. The extended warranty will cover certain repairs for either a designated number of years or miles. Extended auto warranties can be purchased at the dealership or online through a third-party provider, sometimes known as an aftermarket warranty. The Office of the Commissioner of Insurance outlines helpful tips to guide your understanding of extended auto warranties in Wisconsin.

    All new vehicles come with a manufacturer’s warranty, but only some used cars have a warranty of any kind. The used car window sticker, known as the Wisconsin buyers guide, will tell you if the used vehicle comes with a “dealer limited warranty” or if the manufacturer’s warranty is still in effect. If there’s still a warranty, consult the seller to find out how to transfer the warranty to your name. Many vehicles come without a warranty and are advertised “as is.”

    Impacts of winter weather and potholes on your car

    Milwaukeeans are likely to run into car trouble due to our intense winters. Extreme cold can freeze your battery and thicken fluids, including oil, antifreeze, power steering, brake and transmission fluids.

    Moisture on the roads constantly melts and refreezes, breaking pavement and creating potholes. Milwaukee has an extensive number of potholes. In fact, 48 percent of our streets are rated “poor.” Hitting a pothole can puncture your tire or crack the wheel. In extreme cases, potholes can damage your struts, shocks or put dents in the body. An auto warranty can help pay for the costs of repair.

    Each extended auto warranty has its own features, so be sure to read the contract carefully. Find out if your service contract provides bumper-to-bumper coverage (covering the whole vehicle) or only a portion, such as repairs to the engine. Many of these contracts have restrictions where your vehicle can be repaired, so if you have a preferred repair shop, make sure it is in-network for your service protection plan.

    Extended Auto Warranty Reviews


    Endurance is a warranty provider backed by an A.M. Best “A” rated insurance company. They offer a 30-day money back guarantee, roadside assistance and choose-your-own-coverage options. Unlike many other protection plan vendors, Endurance is the direct administrator of most of its plans, so there’s no middleman.

    Endurance Visit Website (855) 329-7711


    As one of the largest extended auto warranty providers in the country, CARCHEX has been in business for more than a decade. They’re an accredited A+ business with the Better Business Bureau and work with administrators from all over to find you the highest level of coverage for the lowest possible price.

    CARCHEX Visit Website (866) 254-0172

    Infinite Auto

    Infinite Auto Protection offers three extended auto warranty plans. Each comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee and 24/7 roadside assistance. Customers like being able to take their vehicles to any dealership or certified repair shop and say Infinite Auto Protection has an efficient claims process and low deductible.

    Infinite Auto Visit Website (734) 366-4354